http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/27/opinion/27george.html?_r=1&pa...

February 27, 2009

OP-ED CONTRIBUTOR

Yellow Is the New Green

By ROSE GEORGE
Woolley, England

IN the far reaches of Shaanxi Province in northern China, in an apple-producing village named Ganquanfang, I recently visited a house belonging to two cheery primary-school teachers, Zhang Min Shu and his wife, Wu Zhaoxian. Their house wasn’t exceptional — a spacious yard, several rooms — except for the bathroom. There, up a few steps on a tiled platform, sat a toilet unlike any I’d seen. Its pan was divided in two: solid waste went in the back, and the front compartment collected urine. The liquids and solids can, after a decent period of storage and composting, be applied to the fields as pathogen-free, expense-free fertilizer.

From being unsure of wanting a toilet near the house in the first place — which is why the bathroom is at the far end of their courtyard — the couple had become so delighted with it that they regretted not putting it next to the kitchen after all.

What does this have to do with you? Mr. Zhang and Ms. Wu’s weird toilet — known as a “urine diversion,” or NoMix (after a Swedish brand), toilet — may have things to teach us all.

In the industrialized world, most of us (except those who have septic tanks) rely on wastewater-treatment plants to remove our excrement from the drinking-water supply, in great volumes. (Toilets can use up to 30 percent of a household’s water supply.) This paradigm is rarely questioned, and I understand why: flush toilets, sewers and wastewater-treatment plants do a fine job of separating us from our potentially toxic waste, and eliminating cholera and other waterborne diseases. Without them, cities wouldn’t work.

But the paradigm is flawed. For a start, cleaning sewage guzzles energy. Sewage treatment in Britain uses a quarter of the energy generated by the country’s largest coal-fired power station.

Then there is the nutrient problem: Human excrement is rich in nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, which is why it has been a good fertilizer for millenniums and until surprisingly recently. (A 19th-century “sewage farm” in Pasadena, Calif., was renowned for its tasty walnuts.) But when sewage is dumped in the seas in great quantity, these nutrients can unbalance and sometimes suffocate life, contributing to dead zones (405 worldwide and counting, according to a recent study). Sewage, according to the United Nations Environment Program, is the biggest marine pollutant there is. Wastewater-treatment plants work to extract the nutrients before discharging sewage into water courses, but they can’t remove them all.

And there’s also the urine problem. Urine, like any liquid, is a headache for wastewater managers, because most sewer systems take water from street drains along with the toilet, shower and kitchen kind. Population growth is already taxing sewers. (London’s great network was built in the late 19th century with 25 percent extra capacity, but a system designed for three million people must now serve more than twice as many.) When a rainstorm suddenly sends millions of gallons of water into an already overloaded system, the extra must be stored or — if storage is lacking — discharged, untreated, into the nearest river or harbor. Each week, New York City sends about 800 Olympic-size swimming pools’ worth of sewage-polluted water into nearby waters because there’s nowhere else for it to go.

This probably won’t kill us, but it’s not ideal. Environmental scientists in California have calculated that sewage discharged near 28 Southern California beaches has contributed to up to 1.5 million excess gastrointestinal illnesses, costing as much as $51 million in health care. We can do better.

Urine might be one way forward. Before engineers scoff into their breakfast, consider that since at least 135,000 urine-diversion toilets are in use in Sweden and that a Swiss aquatic institute did a six-year study of urine separation that found in its favor. In Sweden, some of the collected urine — which contains 80 percent of the nutrients in excrement — is given to farmers, with little objection. “If they can use urine and it’s cheap, they’ll use it,” said Petter Jenssen, a professor at the Agricultural University of Norway.

The price of phosphorus fertilizers rose 50 percent in the past year in some parts of the world, as phosphate reserves, the largest of which are in Morocco and China, dwindle. (The gloomiest predictions suggest they’ll be gone in 100 years.) Although half of sewage sludge in the United States is already turned into cheap fertilizer known as “biosolids,” urine contains hardly any of the pathogens or heavy metals that critics of biosolids claim remain in mixed sewage, despite treatment.

The rest of Sweden’s collected urine goes to municipal wastewater plants, but in much smaller volume so it’s easier to deal with. Research by Jac Wilsenach, now a civil engineer in South Africa, found that removing even half of the nutrient-rich urine enables the bacteria in the aeration tanks to munch all the nitrogen and phosphate matter in solid waste in a single day rather than the usual 30. Urine diversion also makes for richer sludge and produces more methane, which can be turned into gas or electricity, Mr. Wilsenach said. In short, separating urine turns a guzzler of energy into a net producer.

Putting urine to use is not new. A friend’s grandmother remembers the man coming round for the buckets 60 years ago in Yorkshire, which were then sold to the tanning industry. The flush toilet ended that, and no one — my friend’s nan included — wants outside privies again. “Any innovation in the toilet that increases owner responsibility is probably seen as downwardly mobile,” said Carol Steinfeld, of New Bedford, Mass., who imports NoMix toilets into the United States.

Then there’s the sitting problem: in most urine-diversion toilets, a man must empty his bladder sitting down. This wouldn’t be a problem in some countries — Germany recently introduced a toilet-seat alarm that admonishes standers to sit — but it has been in others. Professor Jenssen was flummoxed by one participant at a training workshop in Cuba who said firmly, “If a man sits, he is homosexual.”

For now, “ecological sanitation” — or more sustainable sewage disposal — thrives mostly in fast-industrializing countries like China and India, which have money to invest in alternatives but few sewers. A subculture of composting toilets exists in the United States, but only a few hundred urine-diversion toilets have been imported, Ms. Steinfeld said.

Necessity — whether occasioned by fertilizer prices, carbon footprints or crippling capital investments — could bring change. At a recent wastewater conference, I watched in astonishment as dour engineers rushed to question a speaker who had been talking about stabilization ponds, which clean sewage using water, flow control, bacteria and light. Normally, such things would be cast into the box of hippie-ish ecological sanitation. But to managers struggling with energy quotas and budget limitations, more sustainable, less energy-intensive sanitation may be starting to make sense.

As Mr. Zhang told me with a smile: “For me, whatever the toilet is, I use it. For example, here we eat wheat. When we go to the south of China, we eat rice. Otherwise we starve.”

It’s been more than 100 years since Teddy Roosevelt wondered aloud whether “civilized people ought to know how to dispose of the sewage in some other way than putting it into the drinking water.” The Zhang family toilet is not the perfect answer to Roosevelt, as it still uses some water, though 80 percent less than a regular flush toilet uses. But at least it’s the result of someone asking the right questions.

Rose George is the author of “The Big Necessity: The Unmentionable World of Human Waste and Why It Matters.”

Views: 30

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

As some of you may recall, fertiling plants with urine (by peeing outside) was one of the Top Permaculture Things You Can Do Right Now by Larry Santoyo in the March/April 2008 issue of HopeDance; to see the others, read more here:http://www.hopedance.org/cms/content/view/480/107/
thanks Kathryn,

3) Pee Outside!
Yep, dogs do it, birds do it, even bees do it...! Please pee freely -- not on the sidewalk or behind the bar! -- but in your garden, and around your trees and bushes. Urine is sterile, composed largely of nitrogen, and nitrogen is what plants need. All you have to do when you pee on your garden is to remember to water your plants at some point to dilute the dosage and avoid fertilizer burn. Sponsor a circle garden of sunflowers or sun-chokes in your own backyard: make it large enough to step into the middle, and grow a privacy screen. A clump of bamboo would also be happy with becoming a living pee processor. Females may find it useful to grow plants nearby with soft, fuzzy leaves, such as lambs ears (Stachys sp.) or mullein (Verbascum sp.) or fragrant herbs such as mint and lavender. I’ve also seen great garlic and onions grown using this “PeePeePonics” method. NOTE: It’s important to practice this...where the neighbors can’t see you.>>


bob
I was overjoyed when I saw this in the Times! I am an avid urine saver, peeing into containers and putting it on my compost or diluted on the garden. Love the privacy screen idea, Bob. I am amused by how shocked people are by the idea- we are definitely a nation of puritans. I remember my father telling the story of how in Germany a commercial tour bus would stop by the roadside when requested, so riders could go out and pee behind a bush.

I've experimented with humanure, too, composting it all for a couple of weeks. I was amazed that it really does not smell much at all when you just cover it with something like sawdust. I live in the city and composting it is a little tricky, another thing that takes extra time and effort, and I'd like to do but am not quite set up yet.

ingrid
Hi Ingrid, thanks for your replies...
I didnt write the above.. I excerpted it from the article that Kathryn made reference to, the link at HopeDance. I was quoting the master himself, Larry Santoyo. When I lived in SLO I was using a compost toilet and yes you are right. Theres no smell.. its is mucho better than a regular toilet with all its smells and perfumes to hide it.. the only thing I did was pee and crap in the compost toilet with tissue and all and sprinkle some sawdust that I got for free from a local mill... and when the pot/bucket reached its limits I would transport it (about 40 feet) to a compost bin created by 4 pallettes and watered it and put other compost scraps in it along with straw....

later

bob

RSS

Latest Activity

Yuri Smirnov posted a video

Fantastic woodcrafts from Russia - true works of art!

Fantastic works of art by Russian woodcraft master. Alexander works with different types of wood: cedar wood (Pinus Sibirica), apple tree, elm tree, poplar t...
Jan 28
Yuri Smirnov posted a photo

Applicator Lyapko

Applicator Lyapko - your home holistic healing doctor!…
Jan 23
Joe A updated their profile
Jan 12
Yuri Smirnov posted a blog post

Wonders of Vedic Russia!

My dear friends!January is a good time to make up your plans for the year. )  We invite you to…See More
Jan 3
Yuri Smirnov posted videos
Jan 3
Yuri Smirnov posted a video

Welcome to Vedic Russia Ethno-Eco-tour!

Come and see sacred places of Vedic Russia, astounding dolmens and megaliths, join art and folklore festivals and Vedic Russia gatherings and explore the lif...
Dec 3, 2016
Yuri Smirnov posted a video

Handmade wooden bowl (Pinus Sibirica)

Beautiful and nice to the feel dishware made of Siberian cedar wood will bring you back to our Prisitne Origins when we all stayed close to Nature and it gav...
Nov 19, 2016
Yuri Smirnov posted photos
Oct 20, 2016

© 2017   Created by Darlene Cavallara.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service